MelbavsTomahawk

Melba (aroma) and Tomahawk (dual purpose) serve different purposes. Comparing acids, aromas and character helps pick the right hop.

Melba

Aroma

Alpha acid

7–10%

Beta acid

2.5–5%

Total oil

2–4 mL

Australia

Tomahawk

Dual purpose

Alpha acid

15–17.5%

Beta acid

4.5–6%

Total oil

2.5–4.5 mL

United States

Key differences

When to pick Melba

  • Aroma-focused - ideal for dry hopping

When to pick Tomahawk

  • Higher alpha acid - stronger bittering
  • More essential oils - more intense aroma
  • Higher beta acid - smoother, longer-lasting bitterness
  • Versatile - works for both bittering and aroma

Aroma profile and use

Shared aromas

Citrus

Only in Melba

Passion fruitGrapefruitSpicy

Only in Tomahawk

Black currantLicoriceCurryOnion

Property

PropertyMelbaTomahawk
Alpha acid7–10%15–17.5%
Beta acid2.5–5%4.5–6%
Co-humulone25–35%28–35%
Total oil2–4 mL2.5–4.5 mL
Myrcene-45–55%
Humulene-9–14%
Caryophyllene-6–10%
Farnesene-0–1%
OriginAustraliaUnited States
PurposeAromaDual purpose

Related comparisons